Articles - Journaltalk

Editor's Choice

Perceptive, important, contentious discussions—or so it seemed to us!

  1. The Ideological Profile of Harvard University Press: Categorizing 494 Books Published 2000-2010

    • I realize that the strict libertarian would argue against any mandated coverage. Until the US citizenry is willing to let people who fail to provide for themselves die on the hospital’s steps, a coverage mandate for major illness is warranted. I raise significant concerns about any major role for government beyond certain minimal things it can do reasonably well. These concerns are problematic for those favoring a single payer solution. I think such an approach would guarantee coverage, but otherwise it would be a disaster. I’m noticing, for example, that some of the numbers here seem to mirror data about the number of conservatives in each discipline. So if field X is comprised of 10% conservatives, and 10% of HUP’s publications in that field fall right of center, couldn’t they argue that conservatives have the same chance of being published as liberals? Is there any way to see a sample of submissions and or rejections? If one wishes to critique the literature for an ideological bias, however, it is best to get one’s facts straight.OK, but keep it respectful.

      Thanks

      Robert

      Best iPad 3 Cases 2012

    • 5 comments
    • First comment 24 Jan 2011 by Hal Luft
    • Last comment 09 Aug 2012 by Cyber World UK
    • Join this discussion.

Member login

Jt Article Discussions

Most recent article-specific discussions at Journaltalk.

30 Sep

To Have and Have Not: Response to Commentators
Overreaching on Genes
On Clark's Book on the Determinants of Social Status in England, 1600–2026
Survival of the Richest
For Clark’s Consideration: Genotypic Population Stratification and Non-Additive Genetic Effects
Who’s Afraid of Gregory Clark?
Journaltalk: Opening the journals to civil voices everywhere!

All contents © 2026 by Daniel Klein unless otherwise attributed. All rights reserved.