Journaltalk

Open commentary on scholarly articles.

Welcome to Journaltalk: the platform of article-specific discussions. All content is user-driven.

Learn more: Take the 60 second Journaltalk tour.

  1. Find Discussions of articles.
  2. Join Discussions to comment on articles in leading journals.
  3. Add Article Info to open new discussions.

Why should I use Jt?

  • Jt exposes what lies between the lines.
  • Jt criticism helps me see how academic publishing really works.
  • When I read an article I sometimes find serious problems. Jt enables me to develop my criticisms.
  • Jt enables me to air my criticisms of an article.
  • Jt makes researchers accountable. The critical commentary makes fascinating reading.
  • Jt shows me which articles in my field people care about.
  • Jt shows me how readers react to articles I've published.
  • I use Jt to post updates and second-thoughts about my own articles.

Newest Comments

  1. Aiqi Sun commented on In Defense of Synthetic Karl Marx: A Reply to Joseph Francis at 01:10 AM22 Oct.
  2. Jon Nelson commented on McCloskey's 1988 Letter Responding to a Letter from the President of Penn State at 06:11 PM02 Nov.
  3. Jon Nelson commented on McCloskey's 1988 Letter Responding to a Letter from the President of Penn State at 12:11 PM.
  4. Daniel Klein commented on Dissing "The Theory of Moral Sentiments": Twenty-Six Critics, from 1765 to 1949 at 07:01 PM31 Jan.
  5. David Emanuel Andersson commented on Hemma bast at 11:10 AM08 Oct.

Jt Newsfeed feed

Most recent news from Journaltalk.

02 Mar

Michael Nielsen: Toward a more open scientific culture
Read more»
Journaltalk: Opening the journals to civil voices everywhere!

All contents © 2025 by Daniel Klein unless otherwise attributed. All rights reserved.